|
|
| |
| Options for financing international trade |
Open account trading relies on clean payments being remitted to your account and this is where delays can occur which has a negative impact on cash flow. Various financing schemes are available but documentation is required by any lender to ensure shipments have been actioned against firm orders. The various schemes will be detailed later in this section.
|
| Financing against Bills for Collection |
Bills for Collection are handled from the time documents are lodged at the sellers bank until payment is received in their bank account.
The seller does not receive payment for the goods until the buyer pays his bank, i.e., the collecting bank is collecting payment on behalf of the seller through the banking system.
Finance can be arranged on presentation of the documents at the remitting bank (sellers bank). The sellers bank will negotiate (finance) up to 100% of the invoice amount on a "recourse basis", i.e., if the collection is not paid by the buyer the financing bank will debit the sellers account with the amount of the finance plus accrued interest. This is called Bill for negotiation.
Exporters will be required to arrange a negotiation facility with their bankers before availing themselves of this facility. The bank will mark the advance as a "Contingent liability" which demonstrates that they have a potential claim against their customer should the collection remain unpaid. The full amount of the advance is marked as a contingent liability.
Many exporters maintain credit insurance policies to protect themselves from potential bad debts. The credit insurance policies can be assigned to the lending banks to support any advances made under the bill for negotiation facility. Many banks will reduce the level of contingent liability if credit insurance policies are assigned. |
|
|
Copy of the order submitted by the buyer. |
|
 |
Evidence of shipment or if the shipment is by road evidence of delivery
( if possible) |
|
|
Copy of invoice submitted to the buyer. |
| |
|
|
|
Bill for negotiation without credit insurance |
1 |
|
Contingent liability 100% |
2 |
|
Advance £100,000 |
3 |
|
Liability £100,000 |
| Bill for negotiation with credit insurance |
1 |
|
Contingent liability 20% |
2 |
|
Advance £100,000 |
3 |
|
Liability £20,000 balance is covered by the assignment of the credit insurance policy |
|
|
| |
 |
| |
| Export Finance Schemes operated by the UK Government |
There was a preponderance of export finance schemes a few years ago but these have steadily declined over the years. However, the credit insurers have sought to reestablish this market with schemes designed for the smaller exporters and managed by a third party, enabling banks to provide the finance against approved debts.
One of the reasons for the demise of these schemes, which still has not been resolved, was the competition between branch and international divisions for the lending. 90% of all exports are financed through the exporter's overdraft facility and, therefore, many domestic bankers were reluctant to introduce these schemes to their customers. Furthermore, many exporters felt that these schemes may have been more expensive than the traditional overdrafts.
Most banks currently in the market offer two main schemes: |
Smaller Exporter Scheme
The smaller exporters scheme is designed for exporters whose turnover is below £1 million per annum. Some banks have increased this threshold to £2 million. The scheme provides the exporter with credit insurance, which is provided under the banks own credit insurance policy.
The banks will finance up to 90% of the invoice value to approved buyers. The financing banks will provide the exporter with a total facility and then undertake credit checks on each overseas buyer providing credit limits to each.
Most bank schemes provide "non-recourse" finance relying upon their credit insurance to repay them for any advances that remain unpaid. In the event that the credit insurer refuses any claim made under the policy, the financing bank will debit the customer, therefore, there can be a recourse element attached to the policy.
The remaining 10% of the invoice is paid when the documents have been paid.
These schemes are not restricted to exports transacted on a bill for collection as many banks will finance open account business provided the following documentation is submitted at the time of shipment: |
Procedures |
1 |
|
Arrange short term export finance facility with bank and provide a list of buyers and credit amount required |
2 |
|
Bank will undertake credit checks on the buyers and provide credit limits. |
3 |
|
Fees are based on cost of credit insurance and financing charges. |
4 |
|
Goods are shipped. |
5 |
|
Documents including copy of order, evidence of shipment and copy of invoice are presented to the bank. |
6 |
|
The bank advances 90% of the invoice value by crediting your account and debiting an export finance account. |
7 |
|
In the event of the buyer defaulting the seller is responsible for assisting the bank to collect the debt |
8 |
|
Finance is often without recourse provided that there is no dispute of the quality of the goods, goods where shipped on time and in accordance with the agreement between buyer and seller. |
|
|
| |
 |
| |
Larger Exporter Schemes
These schemes have been designed for the larger exporters who maintain their own credit insurance policy. This policy is either assigned to the bank or, alternatively, the bank become joint insurers with the exporter, giving the bank the right to step into the exporters place to run the policy should the export default.
Most banks run two types of larger export schemes, which enables either the bank to manage the whole scheme, providing returns to the credit insurer and paying the premiums on behalf of the exporter. Naturally, this type of scheme can be very costly.
Alternatively, the bank may leave the management of the scheme to the exporter, who will continue to deal directly with the credit insurer, paying the premiums etc. The bank will simply finance all the approved debts up to a pre-set figure.
There is a similarity between the banks' schemes and those of the factoring houses and this is a further reason why the banks' schemes have been reduced in number.
|
Procedures |
1 |
|
Exporter obtains a credit insurance policy with a credit insurer acceptable to the bank. |
2 |
|
The exporter arranges an export finance facility with the bank, the credit insurance policy is assigned to the bank and the bank is noted as a "first loss payee on the policy", this enables the bank to stand in the shoes of the exporter in the event of any default by is customer. |
3 |
|
Bank will require evidence that credit checks have been made on the buyers and credit limits have been established. |
4 |
|
Finance charges are levied on the outstanding debit balances on the export finance account. |
5 |
|
Goods are shipped. |
6 |
|
Documents including copy of order, evidence of shipment and copy of invoice are presented to the bank. |
7 |
|
The bank advances 90% of the invoice value by crediting your account and debiting an export finance account. |
8 |
|
In the event of the buyer defaulting the seller is responsible for assisting the bank to collect the debt. |
9 |
|
Finance is often without recourse provided that there is no dispute of the quality of the goods, goods where shipped on time and in accordance with the agreement between buyer and seller. |
|
|
| |
 |
| |
| Other forms of financing |
Pre-shipment finance
Pre- shipment finance is a much sought after export finance product but seldom available from many main stream banks. Specialist Trade finance banks or trade finance consultants can often structure trade finance solutions with a certain percentage of finance available against confirmed orders.
Case Study
Freckles Manufacturing Ltd was a very successful family run company, with an order book of £10 million. The company designed and manufactured capital machinery which took between 4 to 6 months to complete. Gross profit was 40%.
The Company had a working capital facility of £1m secured by the companies’ assets and was unable to increase its working capital to meet the increased volume of orders.
Most sales were to Blue chip buyers in Europe and against Letters of credit for sales into any other country.
The company required a facility of £2.5m to meet its order book and pay its suppliers on time. The Bank Relationship Consultancy advised the company and structured a pre-shipment facility with a trade finance bank which allowed the company to borrow to meet its growing order book.
The facility was geared to the order book enabling the company to borrow against a large order book which reduced as the order book decreased. |
Procedures |
1 |
|
Facilities agreed with a specialised trade finance bank. Security is based on the assets of the company and the order book supported by confirmed orders and or letters of credit. |
2 |
|
Legal documentation is produced to formalise the security position of the bank. |
3 |
|
Loans are made against the order book, financing the supply of raw materials, labour and all direct costs relating to the manufacture of the capital equipment. |
4 |
|
Shipment is made to the end buyer either on open account terms but often against letters of credit. Payment is made directly into the trade finance account and any credit balance which remain following payment are credited to the exporter. |
|
|
| |
Pre-shipment finance facilities need to be carefully structured to minimise risk and to make the finance attractive to banks.
Credit insurance is often required if shipments are made on open account terms and pre-shipment cover is also recommended. Pre- shipment cover protects both the exporter and the bank in the event the order is cancelled mid way through the production period. The insurer will reimburse the exporter or the bank if the policy is assigned the cost of the partly finished project less the re-sale or scrap value of the capital equipment. |
| |
Financing against letters of credit
The letter of credit flow chart detailed above shows the movement of both goods and documents. The diagram assumes that payment is made when documents are presented in accordance with the letter of credit at the counters of the advising bank. This is called payment at sight enabling the exporter to receive payment immediately. The reimbursement instructions found in the letter of credit determine the payment procedure.
There are several reimbursement instructions each instructs the advising bank how it must pay the exporter should the documents presented to the bank comply with terms of the letter of credit.
| Reimbursement terms |
Payment
The advising bank will be authorised to debit the issuing banks account in their books and pay the beneficiary, providing documents are presented in accordance with the terms and conditions of the letter of credit. This enables the exporter to be paid immediately
Many companies many not have been charged interest because most issuing bank maintain cash deposits with the advising bank, who are instructed to debit the issuing banks account in settlement.
|
Negotiation
The negotiation bank, often the advising bank, purchases the bill of exchange, drawn under the letter of credit from the exporter. When the confirming bank negotiates bills of exchange, the negotiation is undertaken "without recourse".
However, if the letter of credit is unconfirmed, the negotiation is "with" recourse, i.e. the negotiating bank will seek to recover the amount of the negotiation from the exporter in the event that the issuing bank fails to reimburse the negotiating bank.
The exporter will be charged interest on the advance from the date the negotiation takes place until the date the negotiating bank is reimbursed by the issuing bank.
Many companies many not have been charged interest because most issuing bank maintain cash deposits with the advising bank, who are instructed to debit the issuing banks account in settlement.
|
Acceptance
An acceptance of the bill of exchange can be made, either by the advising bank or the issuing bank, depending on the instructions in the letter of credit. Normally, the acceptance is given by the advising bank in the sellers country.
A bill of exchange accepted by a bank can be discounted, i.e. purchased at a fine interest rate, possibly about ½% above current lending rate. This rate demonstrates the high quality of the acceptor.
The discounter buys the bill of exchange " without recourse", the discount rate will depend on the quality of the acceptor.
Exporters with bills of exchange that have been accepted by a first class bank are advised, in the first instance, to offer the bill to the acceptor who should be prepared to purchase the bill a very fine rates.
|
Deferred Payment
Some letters of credit are issued with a undertaking by the advising bank that payment will be affected at a pre-determined date after presentation of documents. This undertaking does not constitute a bill of exchange and in theory, cannot be discounted. However, the bank who issued the undertaking, will often provide finance, charging interest from the date of the advance to the date cleared funds are received.
|
Collection
Many letters of credit, particularly those credits issued by banks in China, will only effect payment against documents, when these are received at the counters of the issuing bank.
Exporters need to consider this reimbursement instruction carefully because they will lose control of their documents and rely upon the integrity of the issuing bank, to effect prompt reimbursement.
The normal delay in receiving payment from overseas is about 21 to 28 days after release of the documents. This delay needs to be built into your cash flow.
Exporters can seldom obtain payment under these letters of credit and wait until payment is received by the bank who remitted the documents. A waiting period of over 21 days has been known.
This delay can have a significant impact on cash flow. The documents relating to the transaction will be in the buyers country and control over the documents and goods will be lost.
Some banks who have developed an expedited collection system and guarantee payment under letters of credit within 10 days, this system aids exporters in speeding the processing of documents presented under these type of letters of credit.
|
| |
 |
| |
| Avalised Bills of Exchange |
Letters of credit are used to provide payment security to sellers, however, increasing use is now made of avalised bills of exchange.
|
 |
Avalised bills are bills of exchange drawn on the buyer with payment guaranteed by the buyers bank. Therefore in the event that the buyer defaults the avalising bank will make payment. |
| |
|
|
|
|
Avalised bills will allow sellers to agree longer credit terms with payments made annually or semi-annually. The bills once avalised can be discounted in the market |
| |
|
|
|
|
Avalised bills transfer the non-payment risk from the buyer to the avalising bank allowing the seller to obtain finer discounting rates if the avaliser is a recognised bank. |
If the avalising bank is located in the developing markets some Western banks may counter guarantee payment although this will significantly increasing the financing costs.
| Forfait |
The forfait market has developed considerably over the last 20 years and is subject to constant change with bank forfaiting teams moving to competitors. The forfait market is very specialised and a secondary market exists to allow banks to buy and sell bank guaranteed bills.
Exporters will sell the avalised bill to a recognised bank which will purchase the bill at an agreed rate. The bank who purchased this debt may not wish to hold the risks of the avalising bank or country risk and will sell this bill to another bank, this paper may be retained for weeks and then sold to another bank who will possibly hold the paper until its maturity. |
| Alternative forfait pricing |
The cost of selling avalised bills into the secondary market can increase the export financing costs and reduced the contracts profitability. An independent company based in London called The Bank Relationship Consultancy assists exporters to minimise the cost of financing exports by obtaining reduced confirmation fees and discount rates for avalised bills by placing letters of credit and avalised bills with banks providing the lowest confirmation fees and discounting rates.
A recent example: A company was selling capital equipment to a Turkish buyer,with repayments over 3 years. The seller was in competition with Italian and German competitors, who were quoting cheaper financing costs. The U.K. buyer obtained the following quotations:
Forfaiting company who wished to sell the bills into the secondary market. 18% per annum
Direct placement of the avalised bills 12 % per annum.
This direct placement of avalised bills to prime buyer reduced the financing costs by 6% per annum and made to UK exporter more competitive. |
|
|
|
|